We try to build our understanding of history by studying the lives of our leaders and the tenets of the ideologies they preached. But over time, their biographies morph into myths and their ideas turn into slogans; the complex and chaotic reality turns into a kindergarten tale of predestination and valor - usually as told by the ones who prevailed on the battlefield.
On some level, I also wonder if our belief in the power of personalities and ideas blinds us to fundamental truths: after all, every year, another penniless revolutionary pens a new version of Das Kapital or a new version of Mein Kampf. There is some invisible force that relegates most of them to the dustbin of history, and puts others at the forefront of the world's most consequential and most reviled regimes. To get a sense of this force, I sometimes turn to the history of things: the insights into the needs, the desires, and the fears of regular people caught in the crosswinds of history, as told through the items that accompanied them in their everyday lives.
From that perspective, the story of money is a particularly fascinating one: for example, the decline of the world's greatest ancient empires is drily chronicled by the shrinking weight and purity of the coins they left behind, while the misery of the Weimar Republic in the interwar period is plain to see in the stacks of worthless trillion mark bills that lined the streets.
Some 28 years ago, I experienced one such currency crisis first-hand: in my home country of Poland, many decades of oppression and economic blight culminated in a bout of hyperinflation that caused consumer prices to jump some 600% in a matter of months. I wanted to show the now-worthless banknotes from that era to my kids - a sort of a gimmicky teaching prop. This sent me down the rabbit hole of first stumbling onto, and then looking for, other examples of hyperinflationary banknotes - finding some that are well-known, and some that remain quite obscure:
My first haul, now neatly framed on the wall, included a 1 million drachmai bill (Greece, 1944); 10 quintillion (!) peng§ (Hungary, 1946); 500 million Krajina dinara (Croatia, 1993); 100 trillion dollars (Zimbabwe, 2008); 2 trillion mark (Germany, 1923); 50 billion Yugoslav dinara (Yugoslavia, 1993); 1 million Argentine pesos (Argentina, 1982); 2 million z│otych (post-Soviet Poland, 1992); 5 million zaires (Zaire, 1992); and 1 million intis (Peru, 1990).
Despite being quite content with this display, my curiosity got the better of me, and after spending quite a bit of time on eBay and in some other corners of the Internet, I came up with quite a few additional examples of currencies that joined the "one million club". My second hunt netted this haul:
In order, we have 5 million cordobas (Nicaragua, 1990); 5 million old lei (post-war Romania, 1947); 1 million Belarusian rubles (Belarus, 1999); 10 million marek (interwar Poland, 1923); 1 million mark (Free City of Danzig, 1923); 10 million Transcaucasian rubles (proto-USSR, 1924); 1 million lira (Turkey, 1995); 1 million karbovantsi (Ukraine, 1995); 1 million new lei (modern-day Romania, 2003); and 1 million lari (Georgia, 1994).
But wait, there's more! I still had several banknotes I simply couldn't cram into these two frames:
Pictured above: 1 million Venezuelan bolivares (Venezuela, 2020); 1 million kwanzas (Angola, 1995); 5 million Bolivian pesos (Bolivia, 1985); 1 million gold yuan (China, 1949); and 100 million Bosnian dinara (Bosnia and Herzegovina, 1993).
Many other countries avoided the stigma of joining the "million club" by repeatedly shaving zeroes off their currencies (a process called "redenomination"), or by getting their inflation problem under control in the nick of time. I found quite a few examples of currencies that made it into the hundreds of thousands - probably necessitating some more framed displays to be built:
Roughly in order, the photo features 100 thousand guaranies (Paraguay, 2004); 100 thousand Transnistrian rubles (breakaway republic of Transnistria, 1994); 100 thousand kronen (Austria, 1922); 100 thousand dobras (São Tomé a Príncipe, 2010); 100 thousand rubles (Russia, 1995); 100 thousand sum (Uzbekistan, 2019); 200 thousand Uruguayan pesos (Uruguay, 1992); 100 thousand Iranian rial (Iran, 2020); 100 thousand Colombian pesos (Colombia, 2016); 100 thousand riels (Cambodia, 2012); 100 thousand livres (Lebanon, 2001); 100 thousand kips (Laos, 2010); 100 thousand dram (Armenia, 2009); 100 thousand meticais (Mozambique, 1993); 100 thousand lire (Italy, 1983); 500 thousand dong (Vietnam, 2003); 100 thousand Mexican pesos (Mexico, 1991); 500 thousand cruzeiros (Brazil, 1993); and 100 thousand rupiah (Indonesia, 2013). Notably missing: a rare 100 thousand reis banknote from Portugal (example).
It is worth noting that most of these notes are of little interest to serious collectors: in numismatics, scarcity is everything, and money printed in vast quantities does not have much appeal, except as a keepsake or a gag gift. What is more fascinating is that these currencies seem to be of relatively little interest to economists, too; most of the sources that discuss hyperinflation cite just a handful of well-known episodes: Hungary, the Weimar Republic, Venezuela, Zimbabwe. Yet, the 45 examples uncovered in my search paint the stability of our financial systems in an unexpectedly unflattering light. And although one would expect the study of hyperinflation to be the cornerstones of contemporary monetary policies, there are scarcely any works that try to systematically assess the causes and the incidence of such events throughout the ages.
After quite a bit of digging, the best source I could find was an obscure and seldom-cited "working paper" put together by the Cato Institute in 2012. The authors devote many pages to bemoaning the absence of reliable sources on this topic, even for incidents that occurred fairly recently and in the developed world. For example, for the former country of Yugoslavia, they had this to say:"For months, we pored over reports from the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the World Bank, the U.S. government, the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Bosnia and Herzegovina's Federal Office of Statistics (FZS), and we were still unable to find the monthly data. We also consulted numerous officials from local and international agencies, but, by all accounts, the information had simply not survived the war."
In the end, the researchers painstakingly unearth a total of 56 episodes of hyperinflation, many of them previously unreported in English-language works. It needs to be noted that the criterion used in their paper is very strict: a consumer price increase of at least 50% in a month. This excludes countries such as Israel, Vietnam, or Italy, even though they experienced many years of very steep inflation - and in the latter two cases, ended up with banknote denominations all the way up to 500,000.
Hyperinflation and societal turmoil go hand-in-hand; the episodes highlighted in the paper - and showcased above - are often associated with the rise or fall of authoritarian regimes and with civil war; communist and socialist systems account for about one half of the total, but right-wing dictatorships have a strong showing, too. Overall, you can clearly identify several major clusters: the fallout from the collapse of the USSR is by far the largest one, robbing dozens of already-moribound economies of their competition-free Eastern Bloc markets and exposing them to the realities of free trade. The run-up to and the aftermath of WWII forms another cluster - perhaps a more consequential but also a much smaller one. And in the past several decades, the haphazard fiscal policies and the civil struggles in South America and Africa come to dominate the list.
But the most surprising realization? All but one of the episodes of hyperinflation occurred in the last 100 years.
PS. Does this mean that hyperinflation likely in the US or in the eurozone today? In my view, probably not; there are numerous considerations, including the structure of our foreign debt, that make it a relatively distant concern. But the possibility of significant non-runaway inflation, along with the prospect of other economic headwinds, is worth factoring into any financial plan - and that is a major subject of my upcoming book.
PPS. If you liked this collection, be sure to check out my "Dear Leaders" folder, too!
Your lucky number is: 20813381